Sunday, March 5, 2006
The Witch's Boy 
It was very good.
Mari lent it to me, so I knew it would be, but I wanted to be clear on the point ;>
I am, as you well know, the type of person who likes to try to figure out where a story is going, so this book was perfect. Gruber threw in all sorts of fairy tales, such that I kept saying, "Oh! Hansel and Gretel! Oh! Rumplestiltskin!" And I was typically pleased when I was right, though I was also a little trepidacious, because I cared about Lump, even as I hated him.
There were a few things that I felt had to be references, but I wasn't quite able to identify. One of them came as the woman and her little family were fleeing the cottage. She stops and goes back in to get a rose. I felt like that was a reference to some fairy tale, a very oblique one--maybe to Beauty and the Beast, maybe to Snow White and Rose Red--but I don't think anything more came of it, unless it was something subtle that I missed.
The other part I am almost positive is a reference to something occurred at the very end of the book, so I won't spoil it. It's in the last paragraph, for those who've read it. Feel free to enlighten me in the comments, or engage in speculation.
It's a very good book. Reimagining old stories is interesting in and of itself, but this book also presents a new story, and weaves everything together expertly. Well done.
posted at 7:16 PM
I spent the day reading Michael Gruber's The Witch's Boy.It was very good.
Mari lent it to me, so I knew it would be, but I wanted to be clear on the point ;>
I am, as you well know, the type of person who likes to try to figure out where a story is going, so this book was perfect. Gruber threw in all sorts of fairy tales, such that I kept saying, "Oh! Hansel and Gretel! Oh! Rumplestiltskin!" And I was typically pleased when I was right, though I was also a little trepidacious, because I cared about Lump, even as I hated him.
There were a few things that I felt had to be references, but I wasn't quite able to identify. One of them came as the woman and her little family were fleeing the cottage. She stops and goes back in to get a rose. I felt like that was a reference to some fairy tale, a very oblique one--maybe to Beauty and the Beast, maybe to Snow White and Rose Red--but I don't think anything more came of it, unless it was something subtle that I missed.
The other part I am almost positive is a reference to something occurred at the very end of the book, so I won't spoil it. It's in the last paragraph, for those who've read it. Feel free to enlighten me in the comments, or engage in speculation.
It's a very good book. Reimagining old stories is interesting in and of itself, but this book also presents a new story, and weaves everything together expertly. Well done.
Comments:
Post a Comment
